Ottermann R. (2006) Review Essay: Konstruktivismus ist die Erfindung eines Kritikers. Historical Social Research / Historische Sozialforschung 31(3): 211–244. https://cepa.info/7071
Review Essay: Konstruktivismus ist die Erfindung eines Kritikers. [Review essay: Constructivism is a critic's invention]
Historical Social Research / Historische Sozialforschung 31(3): 211–244.
Fulltext at https://cepa.info/7071
Reviewed Work: Wahrheit ist die Erfindung eines Lügners. Gespräche für Skeptiker (6. Aufl.) by Heinz v. Foerster, Bernhard Pörksen. The world, as we perceive it, is our own invention, so we always invent and never discover realities. This main thesis is grounded on neurophysiological research. But how radical then is FOERSTER’s constructivism „really“? Is it not also an empirical as well as a social constructivism plus some realism in it, too? And what shall we do with such academic questions if „the way in which a question is asked determines the way in which an answer may be found“? The physicist and philosopher Heinz von FOERSTER and the journalist and communication scientist Bernhard PÖRKSEN talk about the sensual perception of human beings and the borders of our capacity for knowledge, communication and understanding. They debate about truth, objectivity and responsibility and discuss the connections between knowledge, ethics and practice. I have been enriched of some of the aphorisms, anecdotes and aporias, still, I am not able to answer the questions asked above conclusively. The book is interesting for people who love sophistic conversions, but it is not very helpful for qualitative social research.